| Year | Final |
| 2004 | Messiah 21, FDU-Florham 11 |
| 2003 | Widener 16, Messiah 9 |
| 2002 | Widener 9, Lycoming 8 |
| 2001 | Messiah 18, Lycoming 12 |
| 2000 | Widener (Regular Season) - No Playoff |
| 1999 | Widener 10, Lycoming 2 |
| 1998 | Widener 22, Drew 7 |
| 1997 | Widener (Regular Season) - No Playoff |
| 1996 | Widener (Regular Season) - No Playoff |
| 1995 | Scranton (Regular Season) - No Playoff |
| 1994 | Drew (Regular Season) - No Playoff |
| 1993 | Gettysburg |
| 1992 | Gettysburg 17, Washington 10 |
| 1991 | Gettysburg |
| 1990 | Franklin & Marshall |
| 1989 | Gettysburg |
| 1988 | Franklin & Marshall |
| 1987 | Franklin & Marshall |
| 1986 | Franklin & Marshall |
| 1985 | Swarthmore |
| 1984 | Swarthmore |
| 1983 | Gettysburg |
| 1982 | Swarthmore |
| 1981 | FDU-Madison |
| 1980 | Franklin & Marshall |
| 1979 | Western Maryland |
| 1978 | Western Maryland |
| 1977 | Franklin & Marshall |
| 1976 | Gettysburg |
| 1975 | Wilkes |
| 1974 | Franklin & Marshall |
| 1973 | Franklin & Marshall |
| 1972 | Franklin & Marshall |