NORTHERN DIVISION
First Team
| Name | School | Pos |
| Bill Bungeroth | Lafayette | G |
| Jerry Yaremko | Wilkes | RF |
| Ed Monda | Wilkes | LF |
| Gary Kater | Rider | RH |
| John Wagner | Rider | CH |
| Arthur Kurz | Bucknell | LH |
| Dick Wenger | Elizabethtown | OR |
| George Luzzi | Moravian | IR |
| Gary Danielson | Elizabethtown | CF |
| Gary Messinger | Elizabethtown | IL |
| John Peters | Moravian | OL |
| MVP: John Wagner, Rider | ||
| Second Team | ||
| Name | School | Pos. |
| Dick Giallella | Rider | G |
| Ron Good | Elizabethtown | RF |
| Brooks Heller | Lehigh | LF |
| Dick Church | Bucknell | RH |
| Howard Bayne | Lehigh | CH |
| Dave Sinclair | Moravian | LH |
| John Ayer | Susquehanna | OR |
| Dave Bender | Elizabethtown | IR |
| Tony DiFarizio | Upsala | CF |
| Russ Jenkins | Wilkes | IL |
| Richard Beck | Wilkes | OL |
|
SOUTHERN DIVISION First Team |
||
| Name | School | Pos |
| Doug Smith | Dickinson | G |
| Mike Herbert | Swarthmore | RF |
| Ron Duzenski | Temple | LF |
| Lee Krug | Mulenberg | RH |
| Lew Meehl | Temple | CH |
| Jon Boles | Temple | LH |
| Alan Servetnick | Haverford | OR |
| Pablo Drobny | Johns Hopkins | IR |
| Art Jethon | St. Joseph's | CF |
| Bill Albright | Temple | IL |
| Bob Larason | Delaware | OL |
| MVP: John Boles, Temple | ||
| Second Team | ||
| Name | School | Pos. |
| Richard Dwyer | Franklin & Marshall | G |
| Tom Zug | Dickinson | RF |
| Mike Leader | Haverford | LF |
| John Ruggero | St. Joseph's | RH |
| Ron Wright | Drexel | CH |
| Jim Mackinnon | Haverford | LH |
| Dave Meadows | Delaware | OR |
| Pete Katzenstein | Swarthmore | IR |
| Sturgis Poorman | Haverford | CF |
| Jurij Burka | Drexel | IL |
| George Todt | St. Joseph's | OL |