NORTHERN DIVISION
First Team
| Name | School | Pos |
| Art Szubrowski | Philadelphia Textile | G |
| Mike Yassim | Elizabethtown | FB |
| Frank Kanzinger | Philadelphia Textile | FB |
| Bob Freas | Philadelphia Textile | HB |
| Larry Collingwood | Susquehanna | HB |
| Jack Naggiar | Upsala | HB |
| Doug Trott | Drew | L |
| Dave Bender | Elizabethtown | L |
| Bob Ludwig | Philadelphia Textile | L |
| Bob Durham | Philadelphia Textile | L |
| Al Smith | Philadelphia Textile | L |
| MVP: Dave Bender, Elizabethtown | ||
| Honorable Mention | ||
| Name | School | Pos. |
| Bill Kepner | Elizabethtown | G |
| Gary Green | Scranton | G |
| Jaime Burns | Stevens | G |
| Al Whittemore | Drew | FB |
| Marty Slaugh | Lycoming | FB |
| Wolfgang Wessels | Drew | HB |
| Art Kline | Elizabethtown | HB |
| Tom Shields | Elizabethtown | HB |
| Mike Loschenko | Philadelphia Textile | HB |
| Russ Robinson | Wagner | HB |
| Terry Myer | Elizabethtown | L |
| Tom Smith | Philadelphia Textile | L |
| Ifter Abraham | Stevens | L |
| Bruce Tolhurst | Upsala | L |
| David Akbar | Wagner | L |
|
SOUTHERN DIVISION First Team |
||
| Name | School | Pos |
| Steve Weiss | Johns Hopkins | G |
| Jimmy Taylor | Haverford | FB |
| Richard Tobey | Johns Hopkins | FB |
| Randy Miller | Johns Hopkins | HB |
| Dave Sinclair | Moravian | HB |
| Barry Drew | Washington | HB |
| Eric Drake | Dickinson | L |
| Dick Young | Moravian | L |
| Bruce Fechnay | Muhlenberg | L |
| Dave Isherwood | Washington | L |
| Vince Zarrilli | Franklin & Marshall | L |
| Eduardo Olbes | Haverford | L |
| MVP: Richard Tobey, Johns Hopkins | ||
| Honorable Mention | ||
| Name | School | Pos. |
| Paul Figley | Franklin & Marshall | G |
| Frank Ogens | Washington | G |
| Bill Schwindt | Western Maryland | G |
| Joe Grubb | Dickinson | FB |
| Doug Wendell | Haverford | FB |
| John Clishman | Johns Hopkins | FB |
| Dave Benson | Moravian | FB |
| Lou Miller | Swarthmore | FB |
| Jeff Coho | Dickinson | HB |
| Steve Silberling | Haverford | HB |
| Mark Svec | Washington | HB |
| Bob Tawes | Western Maryland | HB |
| Kayode Sokunbi | Franklin & Marshall | L |
| Robert Szeles | Johns Hopkins | L |
| Manuel Casanova | Swarthmore | L |
| Wallis Ramsey | Swarthmore | L |
| Dave Rosenbaum | Swarthmore | L |
| Dan Spencer | Ursinus | L |
| Joe Nichols | Washington | L |
| Mark Sinkinson | Washington | LRon Athey |
| Western Maryland | L | |