NORTHERN DIVISION
First Team
| Name | School | Pos | Cl |
| Jay Varrato | Elizabethtown | GK | Jr. |
| Todd Suessmuth | Messiah | F | Sr. |
| Douglas Edwards | Scranton | F | Jr. |
| Tim Jones | Elizabethtown | F | So. |
| Mark Pratzner | Elizabethtown | F | Sr. |
| Mike Kane | Scranton | B | Sr. |
| Joe Beneducci | Drew | B | Sr. |
| Rob Martin | Elizabethtown | B | Jr. |
| Dwight Yoder | Messiah | B | Sr. |
| Chris Morgan | Elizabethtown | B | Jr. |
| Bruce Stanert | Elizabethtown | B | Sr. |
| MVP: Rob Martin, Elizabethtown | |||
| Second Team | |||
| Name | School | Pos. | Cl |
| Chris Shenefield | Wilkes | F | Jr. |
| Chris Newcomb | Drew | F | Sr. |
| Jason Spodnik | Messiah | GK | So. |
| Clete O'Connor | Lycoming | F | Fr. |
| Doug Alioth | Messiah | F | So. |
| Michael Graybar | Scranton | B | Jr. |
| Ron Rainey | Wilkes | B | Jr. |
| Brad McGlaughlin | Messiah | B | Jr. |
| Tom Newell | Messiah | B | Jr. |
| Castel Dorcely | Upsala | F | Fr. |
| Felipe Galatas | FDU-Madison | F | Jr. |
|
SOUTHERN DIVISION First Team |
|||
| Name | School | Pos | Cl |
| Chris Brown | Muhlenberg | GK | So. |
| Chris Bingman | Muhlenberg | F | Sr. |
| Warren Jones | Johns Hopkins | F | Jr. |
| Scott Stoddard | Gettysburg | F | Sr. |
| Rob Shaker | Haverford | F | Jr. |
| Ian Williams | Muhlenberg | B | Jr. |
| Bruce Meyer | Moravian | B | Sr. |
| Mike Bishop | Washington | B | Jr. |
| Mike Ruhnke | Muhlenberg | B | Sr. |
| Lennie Nathan | Swarthmore | B | So. |
| Drew Lynch | Moravian | B | Sr. |
| MVP: Chris Bingman, Muhlenberg | |||
| Second Team | |||
| Name | School | Pos. | Cl. |
| Steve Hurley | Swarthmore | F | Sr. |
| Tom Bowman | Washington | B | Sr. |
| Graham Lewis | Muhlenberg | F | Fr. |
| Rod Edmiston | Gettysburg | B | Sr. |
| Matt Levinson | Haverford | B | Sr. |
| Frank Kratovil | Western Maryland | B | Sr. |
| Gary Hind | Muhlenberg | F | Sr. |
| Brad Sheperd | Dickinson | F | So. |
| Jim Craven | Dickinson | B | Sr. |
| Jonah Wren | Haverford | B | Jr. |
| Bill Inden | Swarthmore | F | Jr. |