First Team
| Name | School | Pos |
| Mickey Dimaggio | Washington | GK |
| Warner Cheeks | Elizabethtown | FB |
| Fred Mischler | LaSalle | FB |
| Elwood Kerkeslager | Elizabethtown | HB |
| James Crawford | St. Joseph's | HB |
| Thomas Scanlon | LaSalle | HB |
| Carroll Hershey | Elizabethtown | L |
| William Charlton | Temple | L |
| Fred Bayer | Lehigh | L |
| Walter Chyzowich | Temple | L |
| Herbert Schmidt | Rutgers | L |
| Second Team | ||
| Name | School | Pos. |
| Rauch | Lehigh | GK |
| Barry Remley | West Chester | FB |
| Steven Fuller | Rutgers | FB |
| Robert Kessler | Lafayette | HB |
| Lenny Skochko | Drexel | HB |
| Gilbert Schuerholz | Hopkins | HB |
| William Hoar | Elizabethtown | L |
| Manuel Tejeda | Elizabethtown | L |
| George Sawzak | Drexel | L |
| Sal Cuomo | Hopkins | L |
| George Varga | Western Maryland | L |
| Honorable Mention | ||
| Name | School | Pos |
| Larry Forman | Haverford | GK |
| Hellings | Rutgers | GK |
| Charles Kellogg | Temple | FB |
| H. Taylor | Haverford | FB |
| Sigmund Siemienski | LaSalle | FB |
| Mort Lenane | Washington | HB |
| Steve Flamshaft | Bucknell | HB |
| Gyuca Kovacsics | Haverford | HB |
| Norm Towell | Temple | HB |
| Wayne Schilloff | Drexel | L |
| Werner Mueller | Haverford | L |
| Lazlo Zsebedics | Western Maryland | L |
| Ahrends | Stevens Tech | L |
| Benny Wu | Swarthmore | L |
| Bernie Rossini | Franklin & Marshall | L |