NORTHERN DIVISION
First Team
| Name | School | Pos |
| Carl Peck | Hofstra | G |
| Michael Broniecki | Lehigh | RF |
| Bob Tyce | Wagner | LF |
| Frank McCarthy | Lafayette | RH |
| Bob Schad | Bucknell | CH |
| Lyman Ott | Bucknell | LH |
| Joseph Letters | Rutgers | OR |
| Clea Dutkewych | Rutgers | IR |
| Walter Schmidt | Rutgers | CF |
| Peter Jeffers | Lehigh | IL |
| Carroll Hershey | Elizabethtown | OL |
| Second Team | ||
| ame | School | Pos. |
| Bob Outki | Wilkes | G |
| Warner Cheeks | Elizabethtown | RF |
| Ray Truex | Gettysburg | IF |
| Ted Toluba | Wilkes | RH |
| Armand Fernandes | Lehigh | CH |
| Roland Sutton | Wagner | LH |
| Bill Dahl | Bucknell | OR |
| John Hess | Lehigh | IR |
| King Gore | Gettysburg | CF |
| Alvin Hershey | Elizabethtown | IL |
| Dave Travis | Lycoming | OL |
|
SOUTHERN DIVISION First Team |
||
| Name | School | Pos |
| H. N. Taylor | Haverford | G |
| George Brackin | Ursinus | RF |
| Philip Brecker | Ursinus | LF |
| G. Kovacsics | Haverford | RH |
| Jim Crawford | St. Joseph's | CH |
| Tom Scanlon | LaSalle | LH |
| Art Haycock | Delaware | OR |
| Igor Lissy | Drexel | IR |
| George Varga | Western Maryland | CF |
| Sal Cuomo | Washington | OL |
| Second Team | ||
| Name | School | Pos. |
| John Brackin | Ursinus | G |
| Stan Wybranski | Drexel | RF |
| Bill O'Neill | St. Joseph's | LF |
| Bob De Laurentis | St. Joseph's | RH |
| Dale Kessler | Franklin & Marshall | CH |
| Sam Allen | Delaware | LH |
| H. Hetzel | Haverford | OR |
| Mike Blewett | Ursinus | IR |
| Bernie Rossini | Franklin & Marshall | CF |
| Walt Schilloff | Drexel | IL |
| Sam Nolt | Franklin & Marshall | OL |