NORTHERN DIVISION
First Team
| Name | School | Pos |
| Steve Cox | Gettysburg | G |
| Mike Broniecki | Lehigh | RF |
| John Unstal | Hofstra | LF |
| John Nussbaumer | Stevens | RH |
| Bruce Gitlin | Lehigh | CH |
| Charles Crossan | Gettysburg | LH |
| Jack Antos | Hofstra | OR |
| Jerry Botdorf | Elizabethtown | IR |
| Herb Schmidt | Rutgers | CF |
| Jim Dugan | Hofstra | IL |
| Bohdan Domardsky | Stevens | OL |
| Second Team | ||
| Name | School | Pos. |
| William Dickerson | Lafayette | G |
| Rosario Mattesich | Stevens | RF |
| Fred Hooper | Lafayette | LF |
| Richard Collins | Muhlenberg | RH |
| John Canzenelle | Hofstra | CH |
| Richard Bartolome | Hofstra | LH |
| Ray Truex | Gettysburg | OR |
| John Mastracola | Hofstra | IR |
| Lynn Ott | Bucknell | CF |
| Fred Feigley | Lycoming | IL |
| Kerry Johnson | Gettysburg | OL |
|
SOUTHERN DIVISION First Team |
||
| Name | School | Pos |
| Bill Zeigler | Delaware | G |
| Don Snyder | Haverford | RF |
| Phil Bracken | Ursinus | LF |
| Lazlo Zsebedies | Western Maryland | RH |
| Bob Watson | LaSalle | CH |
| Sam Allen | Delaware | LH |
| George Bohneberger | LaSalle | OR |
| Fred Struthers | Ursinus | IR |
| Robert Meyers | Johns Hopkins | CF |
| Tom Pescvaradi | Drexel | IL |
| John Coles | Washington | OL |
| Second Team | ||
| Name | School | Pos. |
| Robert Keane | Johns Hopkins | G |
| Sam Gallo | Temple | RF |
| Garfield Biddle | Delaware | LF |
| Richard Snyder | Swarthmore | RH |
| Ola Oyerlaran | Haverford | CH |
| John Guzik | Drexel | LH |
| Jeff Toy | Swarthmore | OR |
| Keith Johnson | Swarthmore | IR |
| Mario Stegossi | Drexel | CF |
| Dale Kessler | Franklin & Marshall | IL |
| Bernie Rossini | Franklin & Marshall | OL |