NORTHERN DIVISION
First Team
| Name | School | Pos |
| John Adams | Wilkes | G |
| Bill Savage | Bucknell | RF |
| Carter Daum | Lehigh | LF |
| Richard Altman | Lafayette | RH |
| Bruce Gitlin | Lehigh | CH |
| Bill Burfriend | Gettysburg | LH |
| Gerdi Kelsey | Lycoming | OR |
| John Good | Muhlenberg | IR |
| Tony McGlaughlin | Elizabethtown | CF |
| Al Hershey | Elizabethtown | IL |
| Richard Taylor | Gettysburg | OL |
| Second Team | ||
| Name | School | Pos. |
| Tony Santos | Stevens | G |
| Ed Weikert | Muhlenberg | RF |
| Willard Crouthamel | Muhlenberg | LF |
| Barrett Behnke | Muhlenberg | RH |
| Ralph Ardolino | Muhlenberg | CH |
| Bert Zarins | Lafayette | LH |
| Howard Segal | Lehigh | OR |
| Al Gilbert | Wilkes | IR |
| Bill Dahl | Bucknell | CF |
| Eric Yonker | Lehigh | IL |
| Herbert Weiland | Lafayette | OL |
| MVP: Bruce Gitlin, Lehigh | ||
|
SOUTHERN DIVISION First Team |
||
| Name | School | Pos |
| David R. Meyers | Delaware | G |
| Jim Kelly | St. Joseph's | RF |
| Tim Ross | Haverford | LF |
| Orest Subtelny | Temple | RH |
| Hayler Osborne | Delaware | CH |
| Frank Plescha | St. Joseph's | LH |
| Bill Fenstermacher | Franklin & Marshall | OR |
| Walt Schilloff | Drexel | IR |
| Scott Joyner | Western Maryland | CF |
| Paul Adogli | Franklin & Marshall | IL |
| Stephen Spector | Johns Hopkins | OL |
| Second Team | ||
| Name | School | Pos. |
| Cliff Kuhn | Ursinus | G |
| James Taylor | Haverford | RF |
| Ted Wiehe | Johns Hopkins | LF |
| Jim McKeon | St. Joseph's | RH |
| Joe Walls | St. Joseph's | CH |
| Lou Brownholtz | Temple | LH |
| Pius Igharo | Swarthmore | OR |
| Lazlo Zsebedics | Western Maryland | IR |
| Daniel Hogenauer | Haverford | CF |
| Daniel Kopycienski | Temple | IL |
| Pete Dunn | Ursinus | OL |
| MVP: Paul Adogli, F & M | ||