NORTHERN DIVISION
First Team
| Name | School | Pos |
| Pete Stedman | Lafayette | G |
| Bill Schinnerer | Gettysburg | RF |
| Howie Gerker | Gettysburg | LF |
| John Mastrocolo | Hofstra | RH |
| Bruce Bauer | Hofstra | CH |
| Jack Freyberger | Moravian | LH |
| Manfred Borstelman | Stevens | OR |
| Dick Taylor | Gettysburg | IR |
| Tony McGlaughlin | Elizabethtown | CF |
| Al Hershey | Elizabethtown | IL |
| Bob Nix | Gettysburg | OL |
| Second Team | ||
| Name | School | Pos. |
| Bill Huber | Gettysburg | G |
| Vic Ferraris | Lafayette | RF |
| Bruce Jackson | Moravian | LF |
| Doc Nagle | Moravian | RH |
| Bill Cuanmen | Moravian | CH |
| Len Jablonski | Wilkes | LH |
| Al Gilbert | Wilkes | OR |
| Don West | Lafayette | IR |
| Irv Jacobsen | Lafayette | CF |
| Bob Erick | Wilkes | IL |
| Frank Heery | Lafayette | OL |
|
SOUTHERN DIVISION First Team |
||
| Name | School | Pos |
| Dave Felson | Haverford | G |
| Reinhard Witt | Drexel | RF |
| Dana Carrol | Swarthmore | LF |
| Steve Mallanee | Johns Hopkins | RH |
| Jim Shenk | Drexel | CH |
| Dan Smiley | Haverford | LH |
| Don Grabner | Drexel | OR |
| Will Gabel | Drexel | IR |
| Dan Hogenauer | Haverford | CF |
| Clement Dossa | Swarthmore | IL |
| Steve Spector | Johns Hopkins | OL |
| Second Team | ||
| Name | School | Pos. |
| Charles Meding | Washington | G |
| Lance Knaugh | Franklin & Marshall | RF |
| Lou Maerten | Drexel | LF |
| Paul Stevens | Swarthmore | RH |
| Mike Ratner | Johns Hopkins | CH |
| Lew Brownholz | Temple | LH |
| Ralph Mayomona | Western Maryland | OR |
| Dave Rowley | Swarthmore | IR |
| Paul Adogli | Franklin & Marshall | CF |
| Joe Flicker | Temple | IL |
| Pete Setlow | Swarthmore | OL |