NORTHERN DIVISION
First Team
| Name | School | Pos |
| John Millard | Stevens | G |
| Eugene Danylyshyn | Stevens | RF |
| Carter Daum | Lehigh | LF |
| Bruce Bauer | Hofstra | RH |
| Tom Speakman | Elizabethtown | CH |
| Mike Hudick | Wilkes | LH |
| Dave Vickner | Upsala | OR |
| Bob Eurich | Wilkes | IR |
| Gil Slingerland | Upsala | CF |
| John Colestock | Gettysburg | IL |
| Rich Beck | Wilkes | OL |
| Second Team | ||
| Name | School | Pos. |
| Dennis Carlisle | Wagner | G |
| Bill Schinnerer | Gettysburg | RF |
| John Geddes | Lafayette | IF |
| Clem Heick | :Lycoming | RH |
| Bill McEwan | Gettysburg | CH |
| Jack Fry | Moravian | LH |
| Dick Moffat | Wagner | OR |
| Eric Yonker | Lehigh | IR |
| Tony McGlaughlin | Elizabethtown | CF |
| Pete Freimanis | Susquehanna | IL |
| Tom Nix | Gettyburg | OL |
|
SOUTHERN DIVISION First Team |
||
| Name | School | Pos |
| Ed Roda | LaSalle | G |
| Dave Sibrinsz | Muhlenberg | RF |
| Dana Carroll | Swarthmore | LF |
| Frank Plescha | St. Joseph's | RH |
| Dave Allen | PMC | CH |
| Bill Henry | Ursinus | LH |
| Hassan Abbey | Dickinson | OR |
| Dave Rowley | Swarthmore | IR |
| Tony Herman | Dickinson | CF |
| Paul Adogli | Franklin & Marshall | IL |
| Bob Larason | Delaware | OL |
| Second Team | ||
| Name | School | Pos. |
| Jim Bunting | Franklin & Marshall | G |
| Hayden Harrison | Washington | RF |
| Bob Nutting | Dickinson | LF |
| Lucky Mallonee | Johns Hopkins | RH |
| George Kalule | Franklin & Marshall | CH |
| Tom Maxwell | Delaware | LH |
| Bob Leuffen | Franklin & Marshall | OR |
| Fred Struthers | Ursinus | IR |
| Scott Joyner | Western Maryland | CF |
| Siegfried Fuchs | Delaware | IL |
| Pete Dunn | Ursinus | OL |