NORTHERN DIVISION
First Team
| Name | School | Pos |
| Bill Griffith | Hofstra | G |
| Don McCurdy | Lycoming | RF |
| John Geddes | Lafayette | LF |
| Jack Fry | Moravian | RH |
| Willy Walter | Wagner | CH |
| Jack Eshelman | Elizabethtown | LH |
| David Vikner | Upsala | OR |
| Pete DeAngelis | Moravian | IR |
| Walter Kinsey | Lycoming | CF |
| George Luzzi | Moravian | IL |
| Richard Beck | Wilkes | OL |
| MVP: Willy Walter, Wagner | ||
| Second Team | ||
| Name | School | Pos. |
| John Millard | Stevens | G |
| Jerry Yaremko | Wilkes | RF |
| Tom Jacoby | Lehigh | LF |
| Charles Epifianio | Lafayette | RH |
| Bill Ginsburg | Bucknell | CH |
| Steve Sayre | Lycoming | LH |
| Don Spruck | Wilkes | OR |
| Theodore Korres | Upsala | IR |
| Gary Danielson | Elizabethtown | CF |
| Bill Zimmerman | Elizabethtown | IL |
| Jon Peters | Moravian | OL |
|
SOUTHERN DIVISION First Team |
||
| Name | School | Pos |
| Tony Rooklin | Muhlenberg | G |
| Bob Penney | Franklin & Marshall | RF |
| Dick Louck | Washington | LF |
| Francis Xrouse | Temple | RH |
| John Boles | Temple | CH |
| Richard Vallee | Swarthmore | LH |
| Charles Price | Muhlenberg | OR |
| Tom Preston | Muhlenberg | IR |
| Charles Puccilli | Temple | CF |
| John Papzisis | Drexel | IL |
| Ron Pantuck | Drexel | OL |
| MVP: Tom Preston, Muhlenberg | ||
| Second Team | ||
| Name | School | Pos. |
| Douglas Smith | Dickinson | G |
| Mike Herbert | Swarthmore | RF |
| Bob Nutting | Dickinson | LF |
| Lucky Mallonee | Johns Hopkins | RH |
| Tom McKinnon | Haverford | CH |
| Lew Meehl | Temple | LH |
| Dave Meadows | Delaware | OR |
| Pablo Drobny | Johns Hopkins | IR |
| Artur Jethon | St. Joseph's | CF |
| Bruce Jaeger | Washington | IL |
| Jerry Rugel | Franklin & Marshall | OL |