NORTHERN DIVISION
First Team
| Name | School | Pos |
| Bill Bungertoth | Lafayette | G |
| Ron Good | Elizabethtown | FB |
| Jerry Yaremko | Wilkes | FB |
| Art Kurz | Bucknell | HB |
| Dave Sinclair | Moravian | HB |
| Klaus Hilgers | Rider | HB |
| Bob Kline | Bucknell | L |
| Herb Fenstermacher | Elizabethtown | L |
| Richard Wenger | Elizabethtown | L |
| George Luzzi | Moravian | L |
| Rich Giallella | Rider | L |
| MVP: George Luzzi, Moravian | ||
| Honorable Mention | ||
| Name | School | Pos. |
| Richard Kellogg | Susquehanna | G |
| Tom McGinley | Hofstra | G |
| Pat Hunt | Hofstra | FB |
| Brooks Heller | Lehigh | FB |
| Bill Bowman | Moravian | FB |
| Art Kline | Elizabethtown | HB |
| Don Eshelman | Elizabethtown | HB |
| Walt Beebe | Hofstra | HB |
| Jeff Pfaeffle | Lehigh | HB |
| Ben Alrxander | Drew | L |
| Mickey Colella | Drew | L |
| Dave Bender | Elizabethtown | L |
| Bill Ryan | Moravian | L |
| Roy Johannessen | Stevens | L |
| Don Spruck | Wilkes | L |
|
SOUTHERN DIVISION First Team |
||
| Name | School | Pos |
| Doug Smith | Dickinson | G |
| George Leedom | Delaware | FB |
| Bob Preyss | Muhlenberg | FB |
| Lee Krug | Muhlenberg | HB |
| Lew Meehl | Temple | HB |
| Ron Duzenski | Temple | HB |
| Roger Morley | Delaware | L |
| Jirij Burka | Drexel | L |
| Bill Nhari | Drexel | L |
| Geoff Mwaungulu | Swarthmore | L |
| Charles Duccilli | Temple | L |
| MVP: Charles Duccilli, Temple | ||
| Honorable Mention | ||
| Name | School | Pos. |
| Paul Diana | Drexel | G |
| Tony Rooklin | Muhlenberg | G |
| Al Perry | Washington | G |
| Tom Zug | Dickinson | FB |
| Steve Foelsger | Drexel | FB |
| WarrenPhinney | Swarthmore | FB |
| Henri Rauschenbach | Dickinson | HB |
| Glen Swanson | Haverford | HB |
| Barry Drew | Washington | HB |
| Ken Nibalie | Western Maryland | HB |
| Hamid Al-Awadhi | American | L |
| Dave Meadows | Delaware | L |
| Eric Drake | Dickinson | L |
| Stan Jarocki | Haverford | L |
| Wes Bachur | Johns Hopkins | L |
| Ed Gilroy | Muhlenberg | L |
| Bob Peffle | Temple | L |