SOUTHERN DIVISION
First Team
| Name | School | Pos |
| Greg Cunningham | Johns Hopkins | F |
| MacWelling Todman | Swarthmore | F |
| Randy Kutz | Muhlenberg | F |
| Johan Waplinger | Swarthmore | F |
| Gary Ignatowski | Johns Hopkins | HB |
| Gregory Muntz | Muhlenberg | HB |
| Joe Rutkowski | Johns Hopkins | HB |
| Lou Podrazik | Johns Hopkins | FB |
| Matt Zipin | Haverford | FB |
| Blake Pepinsk | Franklin & Marshall | FB |
| Chris Hannaby | Western Maryland | GK |
| MVP: Gregory Muntz, Muhlenberg | ||
|
Second Team |
||
| Name | School | Pos. |
| Phil Zipin | Haverford | F |
| Bill Williams | Washington | F |
| Larry McGowan | Johns Hopkins | F |
| Ed Traub | Dickinson | F |
| Dave Kennedy | Ursinus | HB |
| Scott Schaffer | Gettysburg | HB |
| Pete Anuzis | Franklin & Marshall | HB |
| Pete Takach | Washington | FB |
| Cary Paine | Dickinson | FB |
| Steve Schonberger | Western Maryland | FB |
| James Harvey | Swarthmore | GK |
|
NORTHERN DIVISION First Team |
||
| Name | School | Pos |
| Bill DiBianca | Scranton | F |
| Al Lockwood | Lycoming | F |
| Jim Rauer | Scranton | F |
| James McKnight | Elizabethtown | F |
| Jack Vogel | Scranton | HB |
| John Miller | Drew | HB |
| Al Vernon | Elizabethtown | HB |
| Louis Hermisilla | Upsala | FB |
| Pat Coleman | Scranton | FB |
| James O'Donnell | Elizabethtown | FB |
| Tom Schutz | Upsala | GK |
| MVP: James O'Donnell, Elizabethtown | ||
|
Second Team |
||
| Name | School | Pos. |
| Tom McNicoll | Drew | F |
| Gerry McGrath | Drew | F |
| Don Napp | Elizabethtown | F |
| Kerry Parker | Upsala | F |
| Jim Fleming | Upsala | HB |
| Glenn Yetter | Elizabethtown | HB |
| Pat Kreger | Susquehanna | HB |
| Don Brennan | Drew | FB |
| Steve Jiulianti | Scranton | FB |
| Panos Kalaritis | Wilkes | FB |
| Jeff Swenson | Lycoming | GK |