Northern Division Champions
Elizabethtown
Southern Division Champions
Johns Hopkins
MAC Championship
Elizabethtown 1, Johns Hopkins 0 (OT)
1986 NCAA Division III Tournament
Scranton lost in the first round.
Regional Semifinals
Elizabethtown 1, Glassboro 0 (OT)
Regional Finals
Messiah 2, Elizabethtown 0
National Semifinals
Messiah
1986 ECAC Tournament
Mary Washington 3, Franklin & Marshall 2
New Jersey Tech 2, Drew 2