NORTHERN DIVISION
First Team
| Roy Best | Scranton | GK |
| Doug Alioth | Messiah | F |
| Paul Jellen | Wilkes | F |
| Tim Jones | Elizabethtown | F |
| Rupert Kinder | Lycoming | F |
| Ron Rainey | Wilkes | B |
| Steve Sandford | Scranton | B |
| Troy Suessmuth | Messiah | B |
| Eric Smith | Elizabethtown | B |
| Brad McCarty | Messiah | B |
| Jay Young | Scranton | B |
| Most Valuable Player: | Doug Alioth, Messiah | |
| Coach of the Year: | Rob Eaton, Lycoming |
Second Team
| Jason Spodnik | Messiah | GK |
| Tim Ermlich | Scranton | F |
| Jake Tassy | Messiah | F |
| Steve Moloney | Wilkes | F |
| Pat Walsh | Elizabethtown | F |
| Peter Foley | Upsala | F |
| Anders Moberg | Upsala | B |
| Chris Dahm | Wilkes | B |
| Dan Wagner | Messiah | B |
| Tony Suozzo | Elizabethtown | B |
| Paul Colella | Elizabethtown | B |
SOUTHERN DIVISION
First Team
| Andrew Cavanaugh | Swarthmore | GK |
| Peter Belasco | Muhlenberg | F |
| Scott Walsh | Dickinson | F |
| David Felsen | Haverford | F |
| Eric Lambinus | Moravian | F |
| Joe Fix | Muhlenberg | B |
| Anthony Vattilana | Franklin & Marshall | B |
| Brad Shepard | Dickinson | B |
| Mike Van de Kieft | Johns Hopkins | B |
| Peter Yost | Swarthmore | B |
| Bob Austin | Moravian | B |
| Most Valuable Player: | Anthony Vattilana, F & M | |
| Coach of the Year: | Wayne McKinney, Swarthmore |
Second Team
| Chris Browne | Muhlenberg | GK |
| Brian Redding | Western Maryland | F |
| Eric Wolff | Gettysburg | F |
| Jason Sears | Swarthmore | F |
| Tim Schmidlin | Muhlenberg | B |
| Peter Landon | Haverford | B |
| J.P. Gomez | Swarthmore | B |
| Blake Mackey | Swarthmore | B |
| Ron Chesney | Western Maryland | B |
| Kurt Gaugler | Haverford | B |
| Brad Bingaman | Moravian | B |