COMMONWEALTH LEAGUE
First Team
| Chris Hepler | Elizabethtown | Goalkeeper |
| Chris Goodrich | Moravian | Forward |
| Gary Merrill | Elizabethtown | Forward |
| Chris Tassy | Messiah | Foward |
| Jason Webb | Messiah | Forward |
| Scott Fedezdo | Elizabethtown | Back |
| Bryan Green | Elizabethtown | Back |
| Charlie Grimes | Elizabethtown | Back |
| Jason Hoy | Elizabethtown | Back |
| Steve Mott | Messiah | Back |
| Greg Webb | Moravian | Back |
| Most Valuable Player: | Chris Tassy, Messiah | |
| Coach of the Year: | Skip Roderick, Elizabethtown |
Second Team
| Jeremy Kirchner | Messiah | Goalkeeper |
| Steve Blanche | Juniata | Forward |
| Greg Glembocki | Lebanon Valley | Forward |
| Kevin Hain | Albright | Forward |
| Chris Helsel | Elizabethtown | Forward |
| Ken Nichols | Elizabethtown | Forward |
| Will Curry | Widener | Back |
| Chris Herdman | Susquehanna | Back |
| Chris Kirchner | Lebanon Valley | Back |
| Mitch Murtha | Moravian | Back |
| Jason Piazza | Lebanon Valley | Back |
FREEDOM LEAGUE
First Team
| Daniel Kalemba | Scranton | Goalkeeper |
| Ted Castell | Scranton | Forward |
| Vinnie Conte | FDU-Madison | Forward |
| Marvin Lopez | Drew | Foward |
| D.J. Portanova | Scranton | Forward |
| Mike Bonner | Lycoming | Back |
| Michael Bradley | Scranton | Back |
| Jonathan Brand | FDU-Madison | Back |
| Paul Houri | Scranton | Back |
| J.P. Muller | Drew | Back |
| Matt Pivirotto | Lycoming | Back |
| Most Valuable Player: | D.J. Portanova, Scranton | |
| Coach of the Year: | Phil Wingert, Wilkes |
Second Team
| Mike McNamee | Delaware Valley | Goalkeeper |
| Kevin McCarthy | FDU-Madison | Forward |
| Brian Wukitch | Wilkes | Forward |
| Eric Aaronian | Drew | Back |
| Rick Adrid | Scranton | Back |
| Tim DeRosa | Drew | Back |
| Scott Kowalski | Wilkes | Back |
| Bryan Purcaro | Delaware Valley | Back |
| Kevin Scott | Scranton | Back |
| Tim Seymour | Wilkes | Back |
| Brian Smith | Wilkes | Back |